A in-depth study into ADA winners and what they have in common.
Firstly, let me just state that I have personally never won an Apple Design Award (ADA). Not many people have. In fact, the highly prestigious award is only presented to a handful of app designers and developers from around the world at Apple’s WWDC event each year. For a mobile app designer, winning an ADA trophy with its crisp aluminium body and touch-activated glowing Apple logo represents the pinnacle of design achievement. In Apple’s own words, the ADA’s recognise the “creative artistry and technical achievements of developers who reflect the best in design, innovation and technology on Apple platforms.” So what does it take to end up on the receiving end of one of these coveted accolades? As the creative director and co-founder of a successful app development agency, I was more than a little bit curious to find out. When the 2018 ADAs were recently announced, I decided to stop puzzling over Apple’s picks and look for answers in the data.
By analyzing all of the winning apps over the last five years perhaps I could uncover the secret recipe for designing an ADA-winning app.
So, after downloading every one of the twenty-six award winning apps since 2014, I set forth mapping out the design characteristics of each app, looking for patterns and clues, and indeed I found many. But before I get into what I found, first let me explain a bit more about my study.
Any WWDC fans will be aware that over the last five years there have been fifty-nine ADA award winning apps, not twenty-six. I decided to eliminate thirty-three of them from my study and focus purely on iOS apps rather than Mac OS apps or games. This resulted in a very small sample size of just twenty-six apps remaining which wasn’t ideal but to me it was preferable to including apps that weren’t really relevant to me and my mobile app focus.
At Apple’s WWDC event the ADA presenters throw around words like ‘creativity’, ‘originality’ and ‘innovation’ when describing what they look for. I was keen to use each app and see just how many of these catch words really applied to actual ADA winners. I decided to measure each app based on five key characteristics
- App Store Main Category
- App Purpose
- Interface Design Style
- Level of innovation
- Color Scheme
By analysing each app and rating them using these criteria I would hopefully start to notice some common themes and trends.
The characteristics I chose to measure are admittedly not all 100% quantitative and some may disagree with some of my assessments but I’ll do my best to explain any ratings that could stand out as controversial.
APP STORE MAIN CATEGORY
This characteristic is completely objective and the results are as follows:
|Photo & Video||3|
|Health & Fitness||2|
Instead of going into a detailed explanation of every app, I have summarised the purposes of the ADA winners. The most common app purposes among ADA winners are as follows:
|App Purpose||App Name||App Name||#|
|Note taking||Agenda (2018)||Bear (2017)||2|
|To-do lists||Things 3 (2017)||Streaks (2016)||2|
|DJ Tools||Djay Pro (2016)||Pacemaker (2015)||2|
|Music Creation||Bandimal (2018)||Auxy (2016)||2|
If we lump note taking and to-do list apps together they represent 15.3% of the total winners. If we lump DJ tools and music creation apps together they also represent 15.3% of the total winners. No other app purpose is shared by more than 3.8% of total winners.
INTERFACE DESIGN STYLE
Interface design style is a bit more subjective than the previous two characteristics. There may be some contention around the terminology I’ve used to classify these but hopefully most readers will agree at least broadly with the descriptions I’ve used.
When classifying the UI style I’ve used the following tags. Please note that multiple style tags are sometimes used to describe an app.
A very clean and basic design style based around text, icons and imagery over a flat white background. Most social networks use this design style.
A common, modern style of interface design emphasizing minimum use of stylistic elements that give the illusion of three dimensions (such as the use of drop shadows, gradients or textures).
A style focused on efficiency rather than visual appeal. Non-cluttered and extremely user-friendly.
A strong emphasis on maintaining a large amount of empty space on any given page and only presenting the bare minimum controls required at any given time.
The use of vector graphics and illustrations.
A design style that takes cues from and mimics real world objects to give the user a sense of familiarity. Steve Jobs was particularly fond of this style.
Designs that focus heavily on the use of photographic imagery.
The use of line art and fine lines in general to form either the structure of the interface or simply to decorate it.
Designs that focus heavily on the use of 3D computer renderings.
The use of cute characters and other illustrated elements.
After analysing each app, the final tally is as follows:
It comes as no surprise that flat design emerges as the most common design style among ADA winners. Since Apple’s iOS went flat design in 2013 (or Microsoft before them) the style has gone from strength to strength and shows no signs of slowing down. In fact Android followed suit in 2014 with ‘Material Design’ and by 2016 most major mobile operating system UIs were using flat design, including Samsung Experience, LG, Huawei and Blackberry OS.
For me the popularity of clean white designs is the biggest surprise among my findings. Popular with social networks, word processors and mail clients, to me clean white design represents an absence of creativity, innovation or originality. The fact that Apple use these kinds of catch words to describe what they look for in an ADA winner seems like a contradiction to me.
All I can conclude is that the overall user experience and technical innovation must have outweighed the lack of visual appeal in those clean white apps. It was encouraging to see that in 2018 only one of the ADA winners was clean white.
The heavy use of photography was also popular among winners in previous years but non-existent among 2018’s winners. It’s interesting to note that the two apps on this list that are now defunct (Yahoo News Digest and Storehouse Visual Storytelling) both had photo-heavy interface designs.
After the passing of it’s biggest evangelist, Steve Jobs in 2011, the once glorious Skeuomorphism appears to have suffered a similar fate, appearing only once among recent ADA winners in 2006’s Dj mixer simulator Djay Pro.
The results (below) show that flat design still reigns supreme. Thankfully, the clean white interface style that dominated in previous years has taken a back seat in 2018 with flat design and simple design the big winners totaling 70% of the winning interface design tags.
LEVEL OF INNOVATION
This characteristic will also be a point of contention for some readers. In order to rate an app on it’s level of innovation I am looking at three different areas of innovation; Interface design innovation, user experience innovation and technical innovation. My score will be an average of these different ratings.
|Name||Level of Innovation|
|Agenda – A new take on notes||2|
|Lake – Coloring Book||2.5|
|Workflow / Now Shortcuts||5|
|Yahoo News Digest||5|
As the data shows, I relatively high level of innovation in at least one area seems to be a requirement of ADA winners. While complete originality isn’t crucial, an advancement on the apps that came before is an extremely important factor.
Whether it be technically or in the visual design or user experience, Apple is looking for apps that push the art form forward. It’s interesting to note that the requirement of innovation looks to have dipped off slightly in 2016/2017 but is back up in 2018 (See chart below).
The final characteristic I looked at was the color palette used in ADA winning designs. While the palette may not seem like an important trait, I was keen to see if Apple favoured any particular colors over others. A larger sample size would have been really beneficial here but even across the twenty-six apps I evaluated, some patterns were revealed. For the sake of the exercise i have merged the results of colours that are very similar to each other. For example bright greens, no matter what shade have all been listed as bright green. When an app uses so much photographic content that the photos themselves become a key component of the app’s palette i have included it as a color. As you’ll see in the chart below black and white are obviously very popular colors which is no surprise. Interestingly, the use of a high level of photographic content in comparison to block colors has dropped off significantly since all four ADA winners in 2014 featured heavy use of photos. In 2018 none of the winning apps used a high level photographic content in their color palettes.
In order to determine what it takes to design an Apple Design Award winning app we have to take a holistic look at at the data. By examining the results of the analysis of each criteria we should get a better picture of what the key ingredients of an ADA winning app are.
Productivity apps represent 23% of all ADA winners, making it the most likely category to win an ADA. Music and Photography apps are the equal second most likely.
- Note taking
Apps for note taking, to-do lists, DJ tools and music creation are the more likely to win an ADA than other purposes.
- Flat Design
Accounting for current trends, flat design is definitely the most likely UI design style to win you an ADA.
LEVEL OF INNOVATION
- 4 / 5 +
A high level of innovation in at least one area of your app is almost a requirement of ADA winners, whether it be technical, UX or visual design.
Accounting for current trends, my assessment of what colour palette is most likely to win an ADA is black as a background colour, orange and white as secondary block colors with yellow and light blue and highlight colours.
So, there it is. Based purely on the data, I predict that a flat design note-taking app in the Productivity category with a high level of innovation and a black, white and orange colour scheme is the most likely app to win an Apple Design Award in 2019.
Whether those specific ingredients actually help give an app the edge it needs to win an ADA is impossible to confirm with the limited dataset available. Being equipped with a broad understanding of what traits the ADA gatekeepers have favoured in the past can only be a good thing though. Given the tall odds against winning one of these unicorn accolades, we as app designers can all use as much help and insight as we can get.
About the author: Joseph Russell is the co-founder and director of Australian app development agency DreamWalk. He is a mobile app strategist and creative director with 33 No. 1 App Store chart rankings to his name.